Cakes by Cocoa Bakery
Ready to Pick Up or Pre-Order in Jersey City
Every cake we make starts from scratch in our Central Avenue kitchen. Whether you’re after a ready-made cake to take home right away, a fully custom design for a wedding or birthday, or a cake box in a classic flavor to treat yourself, we've got you covered.
Our cakes are buttercream-finished, made with quality ingredients, and built around flavor first. Gluten-free options available.
Ready-Made Whole Cakes
Our ready-made cakes rotate seasonally, but a few are always here. Follow us on Instagram @cocoabakeryjc or call ahead to confirm what’s currently in the case.
6" Chocolate Ganache Cake
Our permanent selection. Deep, rich chocolate cake finished with a smooth chocolate ganache. It's a best seller for a reason!
6" Vanilla Cake with Chocolate Salted Caramel Buttercream
Light, tender vanilla cake paired with our chocolate salted caramel buttercream. Sweet, salty, and more interesting than a standard vanilla cake has any right to be.
6" Carrot Cake
Warmly spiced with real carrots and finished with cream cheese frosting. One of our most requested flavors in the Heights.
4" Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Buttercream
Our newest addition. A 4" chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream is sized perfectly for two people (or just one - we don't judge!). Perfect for a birthday dinner, an anniversary, a date night, or any occasion where a full-sized cake is more than you need.
Cake Boxes
Our cake boxes are stocked fresh in the bakery case every day and available for walk-in purchase. No pre-order needed. Available in store while supplies last.
Currently available in Regular, Small, and Mini to suit the size of your craving.
Current cake box flavors:
Birthday Cake
Chocolate
Vanilla Chocolate
Cookies and Cream
Carrot
Red Velvet
Lemon
Tiramisu
Selection varies each day. Come in and see what’s in the case, or call us at (201) 830-3430 to check availability before you make the trip.
Pre-Order Cakes
Signature Cakes
Our five named signature cakes — The Cara, The Gerri Lynn, The S’mores, The Natalia, and The Martha. Each one is built around a specific flavor story and named after someone real. From $58.
Custom Cakes
Fully custom cakes designed around your celebration. Perfect for a birthday, wedding, baby shower, corporate event, or any occasion worth a proper cake. Every custom cake is designed and baked by Chef Jessica Isaacs and her team. Custom orders require at least 72 hours’ notice; wedding cakes require a minimum of two weeks.
Diet & Allergy Friendly Options
Most of our cakes are available eggless — please specify when ordering. Delicious gluten-free cake flavors are available. Please contact us to discuss available options either by phone or using our Custom Cake form. Vegan and dairy free treats are also available!