Homemade Pies baked fresh at Cocoa Bakery
Our pies are made in-house using original recipes and the same quality ingredients that go into everything else we bake. Rich fillings, proper crusts, and no shortcuts, just the way a good pie should be.
Available by the slice in-store while supplies last, or order a whole pie for pickup with advance notice. Seasonal flavors change throughout the year.
Our Pie Selection
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
One of our most popular items. Rich, dense, and deeply satisfying. Vegan option also available.
Seasonal Pies
apple crumb, pumpkin, pecan honey caramel, banana cream, and coconut cream
Key Lime Pie
bright, tart, and properly balanced against a buttery graham cracker crust. Not too sweet, never artificial.
Seasonal Pie Pockets
Fun seasonal flavored fillings in a portable and individual pie crust pocket
Chocolate Raspberry Almond Coconut Tart
A delicious vegan and gluten-free pie option.
Cheesecakes
marscapone cheesecake, pumpkin cheesecake
How To Order Pies
Slices are available in-store daily while supplies last. Whole pies can be ordered in advance. Custom pie orders for events and catering also available.
